Priya and Daniel each wore two watches at a time, one per wrist, for a month of runs, rides, meetings and sleep. We were not looking for the best watch. We were looking for the features people actually use after the first week.

Worth paying for

  • Accurate GPS for runs and rides. Cheap watches drift on city streets between tall buildings.
  • Battery that lasts at least three days, so sleep tracking does not mean charging every morning.
  • A screen you can read in direct sun.

Nice, but not essential

Built-in music storage, contactless payments and a cellular connection. Useful for some people, but most of us still carried a phone.

What we turned off

Almost all notifications. A buzz for every group chat message is the fastest way to stop wearing the watch. We kept calls, calendar reminders and messages from family.

After a month, the watch we kept wearing was not the smartest. It was the one we forgot was on our wrist.

Our advice: decide which two things you want the watch for, and buy the simplest model that does those two things well.