It is the most common question we get from new riders: road bike or gravel bike? In the Bay Area the answer depends less on the bike and more on where you will actually ride on a normal Saturday.

Pick a road bike if

  • Most of your rides are on pavement: the Bay Trail, Skyline, Old La Honda.
  • You want to ride fast group rides and keep up on climbs.
  • You care about weight and a snappy feel.

Pick a gravel bike if

  • You want to take fire roads in Marin, the Peninsula open space or the East Bay hills.
  • You commute on rough city streets and like wider, comfier tires.
  • You want one bike for everything, including a rack for weekend trips.
Gravel tires turn a fire road in the Marin hills into a ride, not a struggle.
Gravel tires turn a fire road in the Marin hills into a ride, not a struggle.

The middle ground

Many modern road bikes now fit 32 to 35 mm tires, which handle light gravel. And a gravel bike with a second set of slick tires is surprisingly quick on the road. If you can only own one bike, a gravel frame with two wheelsets is the most flexible choice.

Test ride both on the same hill. Your legs will tell you more than any spec sheet.

Whatever you choose, get a proper fit. Ten minutes of saddle adjustment will matter more than any upgrade.