The short answer: a robot keeps the floor clean every day, a stick vacuum cleans everything else. The longer answer depends on your floors, your furniture and how much you hate vacuuming.

The robot

It ran every weekday at 11 am while we were out. Daily runs meant the floor never got really dirty, and cat hair stopped collecting in corners. It struggled with charging cables and a fringed rug, so we tidied those up.

The stick

Faster for spills, stairs, the car, the sofa and the windowsills. It is also better on deep rugs. Battery life of 40 minutes in normal mode covered the whole apartment with time left over.

How to choose

  • Mostly hard floors and little clutter: start with a robot.
  • Stairs, thick rugs or a car to clean: start with a stick.
  • Pets: either works, but empty the bin more often than you think.

The best vacuum is the one that runs without you deciding to run it. That is the robot's real superpower.

If budget allows, the combination is worth it: the robot for daily maintenance, the stick for a weekly detail pass of ten minutes.